- Payload
- Posts
- A somersaulting success (4/21/23)
A somersaulting success (4/21/23)
Good morning. Happy Friday and welcome to the 159 of you who joined the Payload rocket ship this week. We’re glad to have you.
In today's edition...🚀 Starship clears the pad🔐 Hacking in space💫 Payload's picks
Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up here.
Starship Lifts Off, Clearing Max Q Before Exploding

Image: SpaceX
SpaceX's Starship made history yesterday with its first-ever orbital launch attempt that notched a lot of successes and one very fiery failure.
With tens of thousands of launch enthusiasts watching from South Texas and millions more tuning in virtually worldwide, the rocket cleared the pad, reached Max Q, and soared to an altitude of 39 km before a mid-flight explosion.
The flight exceeded SpaceX’s expectations. In the days leading up to the launch, SpaceX set the bar for success low, predicting the mega-rocket would likely fail to reach orbit. Rather, the goal of the launch was to collect data to inform future launches and rocket modifications. Post flight, SpaceX employees were seen cheering the launch and the four minutes of flight data they collected.
Elon Musk tweeted, “Learned a lot for [the] next test launch in a few months.”
Starships on deck: SpaceX was eager to launch this Starship prototype, dubbed SN24, B7, and move on to future iterations. The launch vehicle is a couple years old and contains a number of outdated technologies that have already been swapped out in subsequent rockets. SpaceX has at least two additional Starships in its high bays that are nearing flight readiness.
What went wrong? “The vehicle experienced multiple engines out during the flight test, lost altitude, and began to tumble,” SpaceX posted in its flight recap.
Shortly after liftoff, SpaceX’s telemetry showed that three engines had failed.
By the time Starship ended in a good-ole fashion boom, at least six engines had flamed out.
Starship could not maintain altitude and control after losing 20 percent of its thrust capacity. The result was a somersaulting 400-ft rocket.
With SpaceX riding Starship Raptor engines up and nose cone down, the flight termination system was activated.
The good: SpaceX’s biggest success was clearing Max Q–when atmospheric pressure on the spacecraft is highest. Also, although a few tiles were lost, the heat shield appeared to remain largely intact.
Needs improvement: With 6+ engine failures, SpaceX will need to improve the Raptor engine design. However, the more pressing concern may be the condition of the launch pad. The massive engine firing sent debris flying everywhere, taking out cars, destroying cameras, and denting the large fuel tanks next to the launch pad. The most significant damage appeared to be a crater that opened up beneath the launch mount after the departing rocket scorched the Earth.
What’s next? SpaceX will analyze flight data, implement changes, and begin repairs on the pummeled launch pad. With additional Starships nearing flight readiness waiting in the wings, Elon Musk has already alluded to another test flight in the coming months.
The spacecraft plays a critical role in NASA’s lunar and Mars aspirations. In 2021, NASA tapped SpaceX to build a Starship lunar lander that will be used to bring Artemis III astronauts to the surface of the Moon in 2025. The explosion didn’t dim NASA’s excitement about the rocket.
NASA chief Bill Nelson tweeted, “Congrats to SpaceX on Starship’s first integrated flight test! Every great achievement throughout history has demanded some level of calculated risk, because with great risk comes great reward.”
Sponsored
Join Cesium For Shuffleboard & Learn About Open Roles
CesiumAstro is looking for experienced RF, Mechanical, Electrical, Hardware, and Software Engineers as well as business support professionals to join their teams in El Segundo, Austin and Denver. On Thursday, April 27th, join them for happy hour, BBQ and lawn shuffleboard in El Segundo to learn more about CesiumAstro’s mission to enable the future of space and airborne communications.
Key Opportunities:
-Power Design Engineers-Hardware Engineers-Mechanical Packaging Engineers-VHDL/FPGA Engineers-Component Engineers-Commodity Buyers
Learn more at cesiumastro.com/careers.
Moonlighter Sat Will Let Hackers Practice in Orbit

Image: Aerospace Corporation
Cyber experts will get the opportunity to practice defending assets from cyber attacks in orbit on a new “hacking sandbox” satellite expected to launch later this year.
Moonlighter is a joint project from the Aerospace Corporation, Space Systems Command, and the Air Force Research Laboratory that will let good guy hackers look for vulnerabilities in satellites while in orbit and come up with better solutions to harden space assets.
“This was kind of conceived to help bridge the gap between the cyber community and the space community because you can envision different cyber defense theories and ways to approach things to make them more cyber resilient, but there’s been a really limited ability to do things in space,” Debra Emmons, CTO at the Aerospace Corporation, told Payload. “This will be the world’s first and only hacking sandbox in space.”
Why it’s important: Cybersecurity in space is critical to ensuring assets in orbit work properly. If hackers are able to penetrate a satellite, they could gain access to the information being transmitted back to Earth, or even spoof the data so operators are getting incorrect information. As the number of actors in space grows, so does the threat, Emmons said.
“There’s just more opportunities to try to take out a satellite itself or to take actions against the satellite or to take actions against the ground systems,” Emmons said. “Part of our efforts are really to try to understand…what can you do as the operator of the satellite and what can you do to the satellite itself to really be able to manage through and survive?”
Moonlighter will give cybersecurity experts the opportunity to actually operate in space, which has qualities like radiation that can be difficult to simulate on Earth, while previous hacking missions relied on off-orbit platforms, like a digital twin or flat satellite.
What’s next: Moonlighter is expected to launch in June and will begin operations in orbit in August, just in time for the fourth iteration of Hack-a-Sat. Going forward, Emmons said the satellite will be available for both government exercises and public competitions.
In Other News
Iridium ($IRDM) reported nearly $10M in 1Q net income.
NASA established an ISAM consortium that will meet for the first time this Fall.
The agency also confirmed the re-entry of the RHESSI satellite, which launched in 2002, caused no damage.
A flash in the sky over Ukraine was likely a meteor, according to its space agency.
Payload's Picks
What we’re reading:
Why Elon doesn’t care that Starship blew up. (6 min read)
This deep dive on the Italian space industry. (15 min read)
Parallax digs into a new theory on black hole-like celestial objects. (2 min read)
What we’re watching:
Jacqueline joined the Off Nominal podcast to chat about the week’s space news. (52 min listen)
Russia has released the first movie shot in space, beating a similar project in the works with Tom Cruise. (1 min watch)
So you can relive the excitement again, here is the Starship launch (4 min watch).
ICYMI, here were the three most-read stories on our website this week:
The View from Space

Image: NASA
In honor of Earth Day on Saturday, a throwback to Voyager 1’s Pale Blue Dot photo taken in 1990.
Reply